Defense begins after the prosecution rests
The defense began presenting its case November 18 in the Fort Worth murder trial of Christopher Jerome Blanton Jr., who testified that he fired because he feared a threat from the car driven by Cody Davontae Scott, according to new Fort Worth Star-Telegram courtroom reporting. The newspaper says the state rested after testimony from medical examiners and a medical expert, and defense counsel then made an opening statement in the 371st District Court. The murder charge concerns the August 18, 2025, East Berry Street shooting and the driver's subsequent death. The accused is presumed innocent unless and until proved guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. No verdict has been verified in the reviewed sources.
The county district attorney's direct trial roster for the week of November 16, last modified November 18, lists case 1886252 in the 371st court with a murder charge and a Defense Case status. That official administrative entry confirms the listed trial stage; it does not summarize testimony or decide self-defense. The separate newspaper report, originally published November 18 and updated that night, supplies the new testimony and cross-examination described here. This is a defense-stage development beyond the earlier opening-day report. Defense counsel urged jurors to consider the defendant's claimed prior encounters and his state of mind. An opening statement is argument, not testimony or a jury finding. The reviewed article does not provide the substance of the medical witnesses' findings.
The defendant's account of the claimed threat
The newspaper reports that the defendant, the first defense witness, testified about two alleged previous encounters with the deceased. He claimed he had been robbed at gunpoint in 2015 and that a gun had been displayed during a 2021 encounter. He also said those incidents were not reported to police. He offered explanations involving his circumstances at the time and distrust of police. These are contested claims from his testimony, not independently verified prior crimes or findings about the deceased. The prosecutor later questioned their absence from police reports and challenged whether the account was fabricated; the defendant denied that accusation.
Turning to the day of the shooting, the defendant testified that the men made eye contact at the gas station but did not interact there, according to the Star-Telegram. He said he became frightened, checked his handgun after returning to his truck and circled the station because he felt safer leaving after the other driver. The report then describes his explanation for passing the other car: he said the driver slowed and signaled, and he did not want to remain behind it. That is the defendant's explanation of his movements and perceived risk, not this publication's reconstruction from surveillance, a finding that he was pursued or proof that a threat existed.
The defendant testified that he saw a gun at the other car's window as he passed and made a split-second decision to fire because he feared for himself and his passenger, the newspaper reports. He said he continued driving after firing and wanted to reach his family before calling police. The same report attributes to police a different investigative position: no gun was found in the deceased driver's car, and police did not believe passengers had removed one. The claimed sighting and the police position remain attributed accounts. This report does not establish that a gun was present, that one was removed or that the use of deadly force was lawful. Nor does it turn the defendant's explanation of his intended later call into proof that such a call occurred.
Cross-examination leaves the issues contested
In cross-examination, the prosecutor questioned why the defendant had contacted the deceased again after the earlier encounter he described and why neither he nor others reported the alleged incidents, according to the newspaper. The defendant offered explanations for the renewed contact and for leaving without reporting the claimed robbery. The prosecutor accused him of inventing the robbery story after the fatal shooting and characterized his actions as street justice; the defendant denied both suggestions. A prosecutor's accusation or question is not independent proof that testimony is false. Conversely, the defendant's denial does not resolve its credibility. The complete evidence and jury's assessment, not either side's characterization alone, must determine the disputed facts.
The November 18 report says other defense witnesses testified that afternoon and that more defense testimony was expected Thursday. It does not provide a substantive account of those additional witnesses, and this article does not invent one. At this early November 19 publication, Thursday proceedings have not been verified as having occurred. No verdict, sentence, accepted or rejected self-defense claim, specific jury instruction or current custody change has been confirmed. This publication has not obtained the trial transcript, exhibits or jury charge; the testimony is attributed to the original courtroom report. The county's Defense Case entry remains an administrative status, not a disposition. The separate guide below explains general self-defense and trial rules without applying them to the defendant's guilt.
Reader guide: a self-defense claim during a Texas murder trial
This is general legal context, separate from the reported testimony above. A defendant's account, a prosecutor's challenge and an investigator's position can address different parts of a case without any of them resolving the verdict. The actual charging instrument, admitted evidence, trial rulings and jury instructions are needed to evaluate a prosecution. Nothing in this guide decides whether the claimed threat existed or whether deadly force was justified.
What the offenses generally cover
- Murder elements and justification are distinct issues: Penal Code § 19.02 includes intentionally or knowingly causing death and intending serious bodily injury while committing an act clearly dangerous to human life that causes death, as well as other specified theories. The exact theory depends on the charging instrument and evidence; this article does not select an unverified subsection. Article 38.03 preserves the presumption of innocence and requires proof of every offense element beyond a reasonable doubt. A pending charge or the fact that a defendant testified does not establish guilt, and a claim of self-defense is not itself a court's approval of the shooting.
- Deadly-force justification requires more than a generalized fear: Penal Code § 9.32 requires that ordinary force would be justified under § 9.31 and that the actor reasonably believe deadly force is immediately necessary for one of the statute's specified protective purposes. Section 9.31 contains limits, including that verbal provocation alone is insufficient. Conditional retreat provisions do not create a blanket right to shoot and do not replace the requirements for justified force. A history of alleged encounters may be part of the evidence presented, but counsel must distinguish claimed past events from the circumstances at the moment force was used. This guide does not decide those requirements are met here.
What defense counsel commonly examines
- Counsel can examine the timing and basis of a claimed perception: The defendant's description of what he saw may be compared with admitted recordings, maps, witness observations and other evidence about sight lines, sequence and vehicle movement. A summary saying no gun was recovered and a witness saying a gun was seen address related but not identical questions. Neither should be embellished into an unverified forensic conclusion. The inquiry is whether the relevant legal standard is supported by the actual evidence, not whether a vivid description or a lawyer's question should be accepted automatically. No defect in the investigation or removal of a weapon is asserted as fact here.
- Cross-examination tests credibility but does not supply the answers: Counsel may examine earlier statements, explanations, consistency and any corroborating material for claimed past encounters. Failure to report an alleged incident can be explored without treating a question about it as proof of fabrication. Under Articles 38.04 and 36.13, jurors generally determine facts and the weight of testimony while receiving the law from the judge. A defendant is permitted to testify under Article 38.08; a defendant's failure to testify cannot be used against that person. This guide does not advise a particular defendant whether to take the stand or conclude a witness is truthful or dishonest.
What to expect in court
- The defense case is not the end of the trial: Article 36.01 establishes the ordinary order of proceedings, including presentation of the parties' evidence. The prosecution resting means it has finished that stage of presenting its case; it is not an acquittal, a concession that a defense is valid or proof the allegations have been established. Further testimony and other trial steps depend on the judge's rulings and actual record. A roster's Defense Case label should be read as a limited administrative update, and a forecast that proceedings will continue should not be reported as a completed hearing or testimony.
- The written jury charge defines the law jurors must apply: Articles 36.14–36.16 address the court's charge, counsel's objections and requested instructions before argument. Whether a particular defensive instruction is submitted must be verified from the actual charge and rulings, not inferred from a lawyer raising a theory in opening or a defendant describing fear. Article 36.13 distinguishes the jury's fact-finding role from its obligation to follow the court's law. After the remaining proceedings, any verdict or disposition needs its own verified record. No jury instruction, deliberation, punishment proceeding or appeal is claimed to have occurred in this case.
Important: General information, not legal advice or a conclusion about this defendant's guilt or self-defense claim. The murder allegation remains pending and the accused is presumed innocent unless and until proved guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. Reported prior encounters, weapon sightings and accusations of fabrication are contested accounts, not findings adopted by this publication.
- —Texas Penal Code § 19.02: murder elements · Texas Legislature
- —Texas Penal Code §§ 9.31–9.32: force and deadly-force justification · Texas Legislature
- —Code of Criminal Procedure arts. 38.03–38.08: innocence, facts and defendant testimony · Texas Legislature
- —Code of Criminal Procedure arts. 36.01, 36.13–36.16: trial order and jury charge · Texas Legislature