High court affirms trial court judgment

On Oct. 8, the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals affirmed the capital-murder conviction and death sentence of Victor Alejandro Godinez. The court’s published opinion says a Hidalgo County jury found him guilty in January 2024 and that the trial court imposed a death sentence after the jury answered the capital-punishment special issues. The appellate court found no reversible error and affirmed both the conviction and sentence.

The opinion identifies the conviction as capital murder for the fatal shooting of Texas Department of Public Safety Trooper Moises Sanchez, a peace officer the court said was acting in the lawful discharge of an official duty. That is an adjudicated trial result described in the court’s opinion, not a new allegation or a new fact finding by this report.

Four appellate claims were rejected

The direct appeal raised four claimed errors. The Court of Criminal Appeals considered a causation challenge, two challenges to the guilt-phase jury charge, and a claim about the use of non-privileged jail communications. It overruled each point and left the Hidalgo County judgment in place.

On causation, the defense argued that later medical treatment—not the shooting—caused the trooper’s death. The court concluded that a rational jury could find beyond a reasonable doubt that the shooting caused the death, even though the trooper survived for several months and later received medical treatment. The ruling addresses the appellate record; it does not create a new trial verdict.

The court also rejected the request for a concurrent-causation instruction and the challenges to the trial court’s jury-charge language. In its final issue, it held that non-privileged jail communications known to be monitored may be provided to prosecutors. The opinion did not treat the direct appeal as a second trial or revisit facts outside the record before the court.

What the ruling decides—and what it does not

The decision affirms the conviction and death sentence on the automatic direct appeal available in a Texas death-penalty case. It does not itself set an execution date. MyRGV separately reported that Texas Department of Criminal Justice records showed no execution date had been set when its Oct. 12 account was published.

Texas’ Court of Criminal Appeals is the state’s highest court for criminal cases, and death-penalty appeals go directly there from the trial court. An affirmed direct appeal should not be read as a report on every possible later filing, court order, or timing issue. Any further procedural development must be confirmed through a later court or corrections record.

Legal context · general information

Reader guide: capital cases and direct appeal in Texas

This is general information about the Texas capital-case process and appellate review, not legal advice. The report above is limited to a completed trial judgment and the Court of Criminal Appeals’ direct-appeal decision; it does not predict future litigation or an execution timetable.

What the offenses generally cover

  • Texas capital-murder cases are governed by statutes and the court record for the particular prosecution. The Court of Criminal Appeals’ opinion in this case states that the jury found capital murder based on the alleged killing of a peace officer acting in the lawful discharge of official duty, a circumstance identified in Texas Penal Code Section 19.03(a)(1).
  • In a death-penalty case, the guilt decision and punishment decision are separate stages. The opinion explains that the trial court imposed a death sentence after the jury answered the special issues required by Texas Code of Criminal Procedure Article 37.071. That procedure is specific to capital punishment and should not be generalized to every homicide or felony case.

What defense counsel commonly examines

  • A direct criminal appeal tests claimed legal errors using the trial record; it is not a new fact trial. Appellate issues can concern matters such as the sufficiency of evidence, jury instructions, evidentiary rulings, or constitutional claims, but the applicable issues and standards depend on what was raised, preserved, and supported in the individual record.
  • An appellate court’s rejection of a claim does not mean the court revisited every possible issue in a case. In this opinion, the Court of Criminal Appeals evaluated four stated points of error, including causation, jury-charge, and monitored-jail-communication questions. This guide does not suggest that any other claim was made, waived, or resolved.

What to expect in court

  • The Texas Judicial Branch explains that all appeals in cases where a death penalty has been assessed go directly from the trial court to the Court of Criminal Appeals, Texas’ highest criminal court. That direct route differs from most criminal appeals, which ordinarily first go to one of Texas’ intermediate courts of appeals.
  • An appellate opinion affirming a conviction and sentence is a decision on that appeal. It does not by itself establish an execution date, a later motion, a habeas filing, or a federal proceeding. Those steps, if any, require their own court or corrections records and should not be inferred from the affirmance alone.

Important: This guide is general legal education, not legal advice or a statement about anyone’s remaining remedies, deadlines, or outcome. Capital litigation is highly case-specific; the controlling sources are the actual court record, governing law, and later orders.