Capital charge and a contested trial record

Wichita County's official felony docket identifies Matison Jonathan Preville Jr. as the defendant in case DC89-CR2025-0855 in the 89th District Court. The docket lists a capital-murder charge under Texas Penal Code § 19.03(a)(2) and an indictment entry dated September 3, 2025. KAUZ's November 10 courtroom report says he has pleaded not guilty in the death of his former girlfriend, whose body was found in a field in the Cashion community in June 2025. He is presumed innocent; the charge is not a conviction.

KAUZ reported that five additional witnesses, including police officers and investigators, testified on the trial's second day. Their accounts covered an apartment visit, neighborhood surveillance and evidence collected from an apartment and a truck. The station also described defense questioning of the state's reconstruction. These are accounts of testimony and competing arguments, not findings that the defendant caused the death. The official docket corroborates the case and charge; it is not a transcript of that testimony.

The court record includes a November 6 jury-trial entry and jury-list entry, followed by November 9 motion-in-limine and related order entries. KAUZ said testimony was scheduled to resume November 12 after the court closed for Veterans Day. This report does not establish that the scheduled resumption has occurred, and no verdict or later disposition has been verified. The portal may require a browser security check before displaying the direct case record.

Video and vehicle movements described to jurors

According to KAUZ, investigators showed body-camera footage from June 17, 2025, when officers visited the defendant's apartment after his former girlfriend was reported missing. The station described differing explanations in the footage about where his truck was and when he had last seen her. Those reported statements were part of the evidence presented to jurors. They should not be treated as an admission of murder or as a substitute for proving the charged offense.

Investigators also described surveillance obtained from homes along Jolene and Cashion roads, KAUZ reported. Prosecutors used that material to trace a truck's movements toward the field where the body was found. The station separately reported officer testimony about a traffic stop two days before the woman disappeared: the officer said no damage to the truck's passenger-side door was noticed during that stop. That is an attributed observation at an earlier time, not a verified account of when or how later door damage occurred.

Physical evidence and competing explanations

KAUZ's account of the apartment evidence included a shotgun, ammunition, a backpack and a white dress shirt with suspected blood stains. Its account of the truck evidence included suspected blood on the passenger seat, a lead fragment in the passenger-side door and grass beneath the vehicle. The description 'suspected blood' is important: the reviewed courtroom report does not establish a laboratory identification of each stain or whose blood it was. This report has not independently examined the exhibits or forensic reports.

Detectives testified that grass consistent with the field was also found inside the shotgun barrel, according to KAUZ. 'Consistent with' does not mean a unique or definitive match. Prosecutors proposed that blood could have splattered onto the shotgun and then transferred to the passenger seat when the weapon was placed there. That proposed sequence is the prosecution's theory as reported by the station, not an established forensic conclusion adopted by this publication.

The defense questioned that reconstruction and details concerning the shotgun, ammunition and truck evidence, KAUZ reported. The disagreement concerns how the physical items should be interpreted, not simply whether an investigator collected them. The station's account does not resolve the competing positions, and this report does not predict which account jurors will accept. The not-guilty plea remains the reported position of the defendant; the state must prove every element beyond a reasonable doubt.

Legal context · general information

Reader guide: capital-murder charges and disputed evidence

The reporting above concerns this particular trial and attributes testimony to the newsroom that covered it. The explanation below concerns general Texas law. It does not reconstruct the death, decide whether an exhibit is reliable, or assert that any particular defense applies. A docket's charge description also cannot replace the indictment when identifying exactly what prosecutors must prove in an individual case.

What the offenses generally cover

  • What makes a murder charge capital: Texas Penal Code § 19.03 requires murder as defined in § 19.02(b)(1), together with an additional circumstance listed in the capital-murder statute. Section 19.03(a)(2) addresses an intentional murder during the commission or attempted commission of kidnapping, burglary, robbery, aggravated sexual assault, arson, obstruction or retaliation, or specified terroristic threats. The additional circumstance is an element to prove, not a label that makes an accusation true. A general docket description does not establish which of those circumstances an unread indictment alleges.
  • The burden does not change because a charge is serious: Article 38.03 of the Texas Code of Criminal Procedure says each element must be proved beyond a reasonable doubt and that arrest, confinement or indictment creates no inference of guilt at trial. Under § 19.03(c), if capital murder is not proved beyond a reasonable doubt, a conviction for murder or another lesser-included offense may be possible when legally supported. That is not an automatic result whenever a capital element is disputed; the applicable evidence and jury instructions matter.

What defense counsel commonly examines

  • Testing identification, timing and reconstruction: Counsel can compare complete video recordings, timestamps, witness observations and the physical exhibits instead of relying only on a selected excerpt or an investigator's summary. Questions include whether a vehicle is reliably identified, what a witness actually saw, whether an object's condition can be dated and whether a proposed sequence is supported rather than merely possible. Article 38.04 makes the jury the judge of the facts and the weight of testimony. Asking these questions does not establish that a witness was wrong or that an alternative explanation is true.
  • Reviewing the underlying evidence through discovery: Article 39.14 generally requires the state, after a timely defense request and subject to statutory limits, to produce material reports, recorded statements, photographs and tangible evidence in its possession or control. It separately requires disclosure of exculpatory, impeachment or mitigating information. For disputed physical evidence, useful review can include laboratory results, collection records and what testing can and cannot identify. Counsel may assess whether expert review or an evidentiary objection is appropriate. These are general review questions, not a finding that evidence was mishandled or that a disclosure violation occurred in this trial.

What to expect in court

  • During the evidence stage: Article 36.01 describes the ordinary sequence of prosecution evidence, defense evidence and any rebuttal, with options concerning when defense counsel makes an opening statement. Objections and witness questioning are part of testing the evidence; the presence of a filing on a docket does not tell a reader what the judge ultimately admitted or how jurors evaluated it. Under Article 38.08, a defendant's decision not to testify cannot be taken as a circumstance against that person. No reader should infer a concession of guilt from that choice or from the absence of a public defense statement.
  • Before deliberations: Article 36.14 generally requires the judge to give the jury a written charge setting out the applicable law before closing argument. Counsel has an opportunity to examine that charge and raise objections. Article 36.13 says jurors decide the facts but must follow the law supplied by the court. A reader following a case should distinguish a scheduled hearing, completed testimony, jury instructions and an actual verdict rather than treating them as interchangeable. This guide does not establish a punishment choice, a sentencing outcome or the status of any later proceeding in the reported case.

Important: General information, not legal advice or an assessment of a defense in this case. The defendant is presumed innocent, and the reported not-guilty plea and unresolved charge must not be recast as proof of guilt. No death-penalty election or particular punishment outcome has been verified here.